Unquestionably the ballads reign supreme--the heavier rock numbers are large and impressively produced with a cheesy touch of soul, filled with brash horns and pub-rock arrangements in what feels like an attempt to follow Oasis but ends up being more like Toploader.
Robbie's lyrical content is still very personal and much of it harps on about what a hard time he has being a pop star ("How Peculiar" and "Something Beautiful"). To fit his new mature style, there is less self parody, although his sense of humour and wry observations do shine though on "Handsome Man" and the catchy but silly "Me & My Monkey". Last but not least, the first track written entirely by Robbie himself, "Nan's Song" is a simple and moving tribute to his late grandmother. Although by far not the best on the album, Robbie will probably take comfort in that, firstly, it's good enough to be on the album and, secondly, it's better than Liam Gallagher's first effort. --David Trueman
Like other reviewers I too was critical of his early work but have since been won over by his undisputed talent and spellbinding live performances.
The first release from the album "Tripping" certainly isn't a bad track, but wasn't the reason for me purchasing the album. It's a fun track and definitely grows on you but the album is crammed with so many better songs, such as the brilliant, "Make Me Pure" the beautiful "Advertising Space" and the strikingly honest "The Trouble With Me."
His new writing partnership with Stephen Duffy is in my opinion a great success, and has resulted in a much more mature album full of great, thought provoking lyrics which he delivers in such a heart-felt manner with all the swagger, wit and bravado that we associate with Robbie's work.
If the United States aren't interested in his work then, to be honest, it's their loss and our gain, as he is the most charismatic and dynamic artist of his generation, and the release of his latest album only reinforces this.
Robbie Williams is one severely insecure guy and feels the need to lie about his life to make it interesting. That's basically what it comes down to.
This album does have its high points, though.
The melancholy "Feel", the emotional "Something Beautiful", the anthemic "Sexed Up" and the rocker "Come Undone" are all very good songs which I will listen to again and again.
However, songs like "Hot Fudge" and "Me And My Monkey" may sound great to his legion of adoring fans at a live performance but they are not worthy of praise for being on this album. It's too self-indulgent for words.
"I used to be the boy next door...if you're Lord Litchfield and Roger Moore" he cheekily proclaims. Yeah, yeah, that's all very well, but while you're admiring yourself in the mirror and asking Guy Chambers to write about how good-looking you are, Radiohead are writing classic songs about pyramids, aliens and geo-political scenarios.
That is the difference between real music and pop music, I suppose. If you're a big Robbie fan, you'll love Escapology. If, however, he doesn't float your boat then you should give this album a wide berth.
All in all, I think Rob has matured and this album is ace playing with every type of song possible, and I think that Come Undone is a brilliant song and just goes to prove that everything that Rob does isn't just Guy Chambers because he had nothing to do with that track. If you're going to buy this album you have to buy Feel - his new book! A last piece of info - i've owned the album since it came out and it has barely left my stereos!
This is by far his best, most poignant album ever. Both the lyrics and the melodies will linger in your head long after his silly Adam & Eve & Steve made-up song has finished.
One night I sat down with the booklet and just read the lyrics to my mom, who, at first, didn't really get why I keep listening to this album over and over and over again. She now nicks the cd whenever I'm not looking...
Also for those who think Me & My Monkey is just an absurd song: have you no imagination??? This is one of the saddest songs if you see past the surface. I don't know if this was intended or not, but if you think that the monkey is Robbie's alter ego (when he's on drugs for instance) the song gets really dark and sad!Feel makes me cry, as does Love somebody. Hot fudge is hysterical, Handsome man IS Robbie. It translates his insecurities and self-ridicule (did you ever meet a sexier male ... chauvinist pig) perfectly!
Anyway, if you are not into the "we're going to Ibiza, we're going to have a party" kind of music, but like some substance: this is the album for you!