Alas! The DVD of the Fellowship score does NOT have 5.1 surround sound. In fact, none of the 3 copies I have bought even activate the Dolby function on the amp. I am sorely disappointed and feeling duped. Has anybody else noticed this?
This is essentially the complete soundtrack to the extended version of the film, whereas the soundtrack originally released contained snippets from the theatrical edition. For anyone who hasn't seen the extended versions of the films - GO WATCH THEM, they're far superior to the theatrical versions. And this follows in the soundtracks - this extended version is far superior to the original soundtrack.
What particularly makes the set for me is the DVD - the complete score for the extended version, in 5.1 surround sound! It's like being in the room with the orchestra!
Some people might ask, 'why don't you just watch the film, it's got the same music! What's the point?' If you're one of these people, don't buy this, because you just don't get it. The entire point of buying this is to appreciate Howard Shore's spectacular score as a work of art in itself, rather than as part of the greater whole of the FOTR movie.
The only reason I don't give this five stars is because of the cover - it's packaged in a reinforced cardboard, which doesn't really look like its going to stand the test of time. A pity, because the collection is superb.